2021
Lexington Carson - Notre Dame College
Alyssa Curto - Ramapo University
Amanda Guttilla - Wilkes University
2019
Lorraine Capasso - DeSales University
Jessica Calabria - SUNY Oneonta
Brianna Curto - Ramapo University
Nicole Fanizzi - Alvernia University
Meg Hourican - Utica College
Hailey McHenry - Post University
2018
Viviana Scotti - New Paltz
Briana Fynes - Delaware State University
2017
Briana Colley - Utica College
Alyssa Dimare - Mount St. Mary
Gianna Taffo - Alvernia University
Gianna Maffei - Mercy College
Ashley Bartalone - New Paltz University
2016
Justina Capparelli - Manhattanville College
2015
Catherine Ferris - Mount St. Mary
Nicole Barbella - Georgian Court University
Jamie Monachino - Mount St. Mary
Samantha Caruselle - Iona College
2014*
Gab Bravo - College of Mt. St. Vincent
Brianne Dacunto - College of Mt. St. Vincent
**Denotes first DK3 Season